Lindsey & Ferry P.A. Central Florida Criminal Defense Lawyers
CALL OR EMAIL US TODAY - available 24/7

407-278-7692 | 877-301-2280

Email Iconwarren@warrenlindseylaw.com

Man exonerated of sexual assault conviction

The recent exoneration of a man who was convicted on sexual assault charges may cause many readers to question whether alleged sex offenders are given a fair day in court.

In the case, the prosecution’s evidence seemed shockingly light. The victim alleged that the man had raped her in the building where she worked. She further claimed that she put up a loud struggle, even biting her alleged assailant. However, authorities found no DNA evidence on the suspect and no evidence of a bite mark. No other physical evidence, such as hair, was discovered on the accused, either. 

Without circumstantial evidence, the prosecution apparently focused on the victim’s testimony and the suspect’s own confession. Unfortunately, the man also suffered from a mental illness and had a low IQ. As a sex crimes attorney might agree, a suspect with those characteristics might be more susceptible to falsely confessing to a crime.

Notably, an internal investigation by the local sheriff’s office reached a similar conclusion about the lack of evidence against the man, although the existence of the report was only recently disclosed. The report contains a material fact that might have spared the man his wrongful conviction: A sheriff’s deputy had been in an adjacent room at the time of the alleged rape, yet he did not hear any sounds of a struggle or cries for help.

This story might serve as a caution for anyone facing charges for sexual assault or another sex crime. The constitutional rights of a criminal defendant should be honored regardless of the underlying charges. However, it may take an experienced sex crimes attorney to ensure that proper procedures are followed.

Source: chicagotribune.com, “Prosecutors dismiss charges in 2 cases: 'This is a joyous day',” Steve Mills and Steve Schmadeke, Sept. 10, 2013

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • The Florida Bar Board Certified
  •  warren w lindsey |SuperLawyers
  •  Warren w lindsey |SuperLawyers
  • Rated by super lawyers Warren W.Lindsey visit superlawyers.com
  • Warren W.Lindsey Best Lawyers Lawyer of the year 2014 Criminal Defense Orlando
  • Avvo Rating 10.0 Superb Top Attorney Criminal Defense
  • Rising stars | Matthew P. Ferry |SuperLawyers
  •  | MICHAEL BARBER |SuperLawyers
  • Florida Trend's Florida Legal Elite Hall of fame 2013-2016
  • Orlando County Bar Association
  • Distinguished Av Lexis Nexis Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated For Ethical Standard and Legal Ability
  • The Law office of Warren W.Lindsey P.A 2015 Listed In Best Lawyers Linking Lawyers and clients worldwide

Best Lawyers Award Badge

1150 Louisiana Avenue, Suite 2
Winter Park, FL 32789

Toll Free: 877-301-2280
Phone: 407-278-7692
Fax: 407-599-2207
Winter Park Law Office Map

Mailing address:
P.O. Box 505
Winter Park, FL 32790-0505

Toll Free: 877-301-2280
Phone: 407-278-7692